Indulge in the sweetest of treats with New Glarus Bakery’s delectable selection of chocolates. Our chocolaty items are made using only the finest ingredients, and are hand-crafted with care to deliver a luxurious and satisfying chocolate experience. From bourbon creme truffles to hand-dipped turtles, our chocolates are perfect for special occasions, gift giving, or simply satisfying your sweet tooth. Shop now and taste the difference that premium ingredients and expert craftsmanship can make.

  • Brochure – Download

    Download a full color brochure of the most popular items offered for shipping.

    $0.00 Download Brochure
  • Chocolate Oat Bars

    A double dose of delicious in the form of a soft, creamy dark chocolate layered over a buttery, crunchy oatmeal crumble crust makes our Chocolate Oat Bars a delicious way to up the “yum” factor any day!

    $25.00 Add to cart
  • Éclairs

    Cool, creamy vanilla custard in delicious choux pastry topped with a decadent chocolate ribbon.

    *NEW Qty 8 per order


    $45.00 Add to cart
  • Fruit Spritz and Hand-Dipped Turtles

    Buttery Fruit Spritz + Hand-Dipped Turtles

    1 pound per order (half pound of cookies + half pound of hand-dipped turtles)

    Packaged in a seasonal decorative tin.

    $45.00 Available November 1, 2023.Pre-Order Now
  • Hand-Dipped Turtles

    Rich, gooey caramel generously layered over house-roasted buttered pecans gets the royal treatment with a generous layer of dark chocolate. Just one bite of our hand-dipped turtles, and you’ll agree – there’s none better to be found.

    $32.00$40.00 Select options
  • Mother’s Day Cookie Assortment

    Gift Mom with a beautiful and delicious assortment of old-fashioned sugar cookies hand-dipped in colorful white chocolate, sprinkled Butter Stars and a Rum Ball chaser.

    As all our cookies are decorated by hand, all cookies will vary in color, decorations & designs.

    Available for shipping as of May 1st.

    Looking to pickup here in the store—-Mother’s Day Cookie Collection

    $39.99 Add to cart
  • New Glarus Bakery Gift Certificate

    Give someone the gift of New Glarus Bakery!

    Delivered via e-mail. Redeemed on this site only.

    For in-store gift certificates please click here or call us at 608-527-2916

    Select amount
  • Rum Balls

    A darkly decadent swirl of Meyers Dark rum adds magically marvelous flavor to these sinfully delicious chocolates. Layered with a soft chocolate center, a dark chocolate shell, and a double dose of “yum” in the form of sprinkles and powdered sugar to finish.

    $20.00$37.50 Select options