Looking for the perfect cookie? Look no further than New Glarus Bakery’s selection of delicious and freshly-baked cookies. Our cookies are made using only the finest ingredients and traditional baking methods to deliver the perfect texture, flavor, and aroma in every bite. From traditional butter stars to our ethnic cookie assortment, our selection of cookies has something for every taste bud. Perfect for snack time, dessert, or gift giving, our cookies are a must-try for cookie lovers everywhere. Shop now and taste the difference that high-quality ingredients and expert baking can make with New Glarus Bakery’s cookies.
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Springerli (In-Store Pickup)
- $25.00
- Ground anise seed gives these traditional hand-pressed German cookies an irresistible black licorice aroma and flavor, and the delicate dough gives every bite of these beautiful treats a light crunch. Available year-round to help keep the holiday spirit alive in both your heart AND your taste buds! Sold by the pound. Price reflects pound price.
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Apricot Pockets (In-Store Pickup)
- $25.00
- Available In-Store Only Butter cookie filled with apricot filling. Sold by the pound. Price reflects pound price.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Apricot Pockets (In-Store Pickup)
- $25.00
- Available In-Store Only Butter cookie filled with apricot filling.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Bratzeli (In-Store Pickup)
- $5.50
- Made with lots of fresh butter for a delicately rich flavor, these wafer-thin traditional Swiss cookies are made in tiny batches of just four at a time on a special press imported from Switzerland. Their crispy texture and delicate old-world flavor will make you feel like you’re on a sophisticated European vacation any day!
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Butter Star Cookies (In-Store Pickup)
- $22.00
- If your “childhood favorite” cookie was fresh homemade sugar cookies, this treat is for you! These buttery star cookies are generously iced with creamy homemade icing and topped off with colorful seasonal sprinkles. A tin of these makes an ideal teacher’s gift, thank-you gift, or even a “just because”! Sold by the pound. Price reflects pound price.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Apple Oatmeal Cookie (In-Store Pickup)
- $16.00
- Available In-Store Only! Cinnamon apple pie filling swirled into buttery oatmeal cookie dough.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Bratzeli Pockets (In-Store Pickup)
- $1.75
- Available In-Store Only A specialty pocket cookie made from our Bratzeli dough and filled with apple pie sauce.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies
Lunch Pail Cookies (In-Store Pickup)
- $4.00
- Enjoy a dozen of your childhood favorites of Chocolate Chip, Sugar Cookie, Molasses, Peanut Butter & Oatmeal Raisin.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Sandbissen Shortbread (In-Store Pickup)
- $25.00
- A butter shortbread cookie to remember! Delicate crystal sugar give these melt-in-your-mouth cookies a beautiful look. Sold by the pound. Price reflects pound price.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Apple Sugar Cookie (In-Store Pickup)
- $2.25
- Available In-Store Only! Apple Sugar Cookie Cut-Out
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Baseball Sugar Cookie (In-Store Pickup)
- $2.35
- Available In-Store Only! Delicious sugar cookie, cut out and decorated to look like a baseball. *NOTE: All cookie decorations vary from picture.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Garden Gnome Sugar Cookie (In-Store Pickup)
- $3.25
- Available In-Store Only! Enjoy the gardening theme of summer with these Garden Gnomes cookies. *Sugar cookies dipped in colorful white chocolate. Designs and colors will vary.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Maple Leaf Sugar Cookie (In-Store Pickup)
- $2.25
- Available In-Store Only! Swirls of fall colors in decadent white chocolate covered sugar cookie.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Mushroom Sugar Cookie (In-Store Pickup)
- $3.50
- Available In-Store Only! These are the cutest mushroom cookies that will brighten your day. *Sugar cookies dipped in colorful white chocolate. Designs and colors will vary.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Paw Print Sugar Cookie (In-Store Pickup)
- $2.25
- Available In-Store Only! Delicious sugar cookie, cut out and decorated to look like a paw print. *NOTE: All cookie decorations vary from picture.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Sunflower Sugar Cookie (In-Store Pickup)
- $2.50
- Available In-Store Only! Brighten your day with this delightful sunflower cookie! *Sugar cookies dipped in colorful white chocolate. Designs and colors will vary.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Swiss Croquettes (In-Store Pickup)
- $25.00
- No longer just for the holidays, our Swiss Croquettes are a classic shortbread cookies with a blast of fruity flavor form candied cherries and a crunchy richness from toasted almonds. Get your hands on a batch to bring back that warm holiday feeling all year ‘round. Sold by the pound. Price reflects pound price.
-
-
-
-