fbpx

Cookies

Looking for the perfect cookie? Look no further than New Glarus Bakery’s selection of delicious and freshly-baked cookies. Our cookies are made using only the finest ingredients and traditional baking methods to deliver the perfect texture, flavor, and aroma in every bite. From traditional butter stars to our ethnic cookie assortment, our selection of cookies has something for every taste bud. Perfect for snack time, dessert, or gift giving, our cookies are a must-try for cookie lovers everywhere. Shop now and taste the difference that high-quality ingredients and expert baking can make with New Glarus Bakery’s cookies.

  • Anise Springerli

    Ground anise seed gives these traditional hand-pressed German cookies an irresistible black licorice aroma and flavor, and the delicate dough gives every bite of these beautiful treats a light crunch. Available year-round to help keep the holiday spirit alive in both your heart AND your taste buds!

    $34.99 Add to cart
  • Bakery Pride Gift Tin – Cookies or Chocolates

    A special gift tin with your choice of cookies or chocolates.

    $39.99$45.00 Select options
  • Basle Leckerli

    This traditional Swiss bar cookie boasts a symphony of rich flavors like honey, almonds, Kirsch liqueur, orange, cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves, all coming together to create a decadently sweet-and-spicy base for a creamy white chocolate finish. This is one seasonal treat you’ll want to stock up on, so you can enjoy the sumptuous flavors all year round!

    $32.99 Available November 1, 2023.Pre-Order Now
  • Bratzeli

    Made with lots of fresh butter for a delicately rich flavor, these wafer-thin traditional Swiss cookies are made in tiny batches of just four at a time on a special press imported from Switzerland. Their crispy texture and delicate old-world flavor will make you feel like you’re on a sophisticated European vacation any day!

    $39.00 Add to cart
  • Brochure – Download

    Download a full color brochure of the most popular items offered for shipping.

    $0.00 Download Brochure
  • Butter Cookie Assortment – Spring / Summer

    Bring home the bright colors and sweet taste of spring with our melt-in-your-mouth butter cookie assortment. A tin-full of five varieties of our beautifully-decorated butter cookies makes a delicious gift for many occasions. Now Available!

    $39.99$49.99 Select options
  • Butter Cookie Assortment – Winter Holiday

    This cookie assortment is a treasure trove of long-time favorites. Eight varieties (yes, eight!) of melt-in-your-mouth butter cookies in a range of delectable flavors will get your tastebuds into the holiday spirit in no time at all.

    1 lb of cookies per order
    Approx 24 -30 cookies per pound

    $32.00$40.00 Available October 30, 2023.Pre-Order Now
  • Butter Stars

    If your “childhood favorite” cookie was fresh homemade sugar cookies, this treat is for you! These buttery star cookies are generously iced with creamy homemade icing and topped off with colorful seasonal sprinkles. A tin of these makes an ideal teacher’s gift, thank-you gift, or even a “just because”!

    $32.00$40.00 Select options
  • Ethnic Cookie Assortment

    This ethnically-diverse selection of cookies from the Old World includes Swiss favorites like Basle Leckerli, Anise Springerli and Bratzeli, and the classic German Pfefferneuse. Enjoy the delicious flavors of the Swiss and German traditional treats with recipes handed down over generations of bakers.

    Qty per order: 1lb cookie assortment including 1 pkg of Bratzeli

    $39.99$49.99 Available November 1, 2023.Pre-Order Now
  • Fruit Pocket Cookies

    Our famous Fruit Pocket Cookies are tender, flakey, and so irresistible! Each bite will leave you with an explosion of sweet goodness.  Bring home the bright colors and sweet taste of spring with our melt-in-your-mouth butter-flavored fruit-filled cookie assortment.

    $34.99$44.99 Select options
  • Fruit Spritz and Hand-Dipped Turtles

    Buttery Fruit Spritz + Hand-Dipped Turtles

    1 pound per order (half pound of cookies + half pound of hand-dipped turtles)

    Packaged in a seasonal decorative tin.

    $45.00 Available November 1, 2023.Pre-Order Now
  • Lunch Pail Cookies

    Enjoy a dozen of your childhood favorites of Chocolate Chip, Sugar Cookie, Molasses, Peanut Butter & Oatmeal Raisin.

    1 dozen count per cookie flavor per order.

    $19.99 Select options
  • Mother’s Day Cookie Assortment

    Gift Mom with a beautiful and delicious assortment of old-fashioned sugar cookies hand-dipped in colorful white chocolate, sprinkled Butter Stars and a Rum Ball chaser.

    As all our cookies are decorated by hand, all cookies will vary in color, decorations & designs.

    Available for shipping as of May 1st.

    Looking to pickup here in the store—-Mother’s Day Cookie Collection

    $39.99 Add to cart
  • New Glarus Bakery Gift Certificate

    Give someone the gift of New Glarus Bakery!

    Delivered via e-mail. Redeemed on this site only.

    For in-store gift certificates please click here or call us at 608-527-2916

    Select amount
  • Pfeffernüsse

    This spicy-sweet cookie translates as “Pepper nuts” in German, and this rich holiday treat lives up to its name! Swirls of cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, cloves and flurries of confectioner’s sugar dance like sugar plum fairies through these sweet snacks – you’ll want to make them a tradition that lasts all year!

    $32.00$39.99 Available November 1, 2023.Pre-Order Now
  • Saint Paddy’s Day Cookie Assortment

    A beautiful and delicious assortment of old-fashioned sugar cookies hand-dipped in colorful white chocolate, surrounded by customers’ favorite sprinkled Butter Stars and colorful sugar-rimmed Sandbissen shortbread cookies.

    As all our cookies are decorated by hand, all cookies will vary in color, decorations & designs.

    $29.99 Available March 4, 2024.Pre-Order Now
  • Sandbissen Shortbread

    A butter shortbread cookie to remember! Delicate crystal sugar give these melt-in-your-mouth cookies a beautiful look.

    Qty 1 lb per order.

    $29.99$34.99 Select options
  • Spring Easter Cookie Assortment

    Beautiful and delicious assortment of old-fashioned sugar cookies hand-dipped in colorful white chocolate, surrounded by customers’ favorite sprinkled Butter Stars.

    As all our cookies are decorated by hand, all cookies will vary in color, decorations & designs.

    $29.99 Add to cart
  • Swiss Croquettes

    No longer just for the holidays, our Swiss Croquettes are a classic shortbread cookies with a blast of fruity flavor form candied cherries and a crunchy richness from toasted almonds. Get your hands on a batch to bring back that warm holiday feeling all year ‘round

    $29.99 Add to cart