We are thrilled to share our products that are available for in-store pick-up at New Glarus Bakery.
Explore our range of delectable products that have been crafted with the utmost care and dedication. From freshly baked artisanal bread and pastries that embody the essence of traditional European flavors to delightful cakes and cookies that satisfy your sweetest cravings, our selection caters to every palate.
By choosing in-store pick-up, you not only save on shipping costs but also get to enjoy the warmth and aroma of our bakery as you collect your order.
Embrace the ease of online shopping while relishing the authentic tastes that New Glarus Bakery is renowned for. Place your order today and experience a seamless blend of convenience and culinary delight.
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cheesecakes, In-Store Pick-Up
Apple Pie Cheesecake (In-Store Pickup)
- $7.50
- Available In-Store Only Original cheesecake blended with apple pie filling topped with cinnamon and sugar. A fall-favorite of the season!
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Chocolates, Coffeecakes, In-Store Pick-Up, Morning Rolls
Boo Z Pumpkin Pie Alp (In-Store Pickup)
- $2.95
- Available In-Store Only Pumpkin pie filling monster mashed with cake, pecans, and bourbon.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Doughnuts, In-Store Pick-Up
Custom Donut – 24 hr Notice, Min order of 2 (In-Store Pickup)
- $1.50
- Donuts your way! Customize your donut order. Minimum order 2 per customization + 24 hrs notice to order.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Coffeecakes, In-Store Pick-Up
Pumpkin Bread (In-Store Pickup)
- $6.99
- Available In-Store Only
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- In-Store Pick-Up, Morning Rolls
Pumpkin Muffin with Nuts (In-Store Pickup)
- $3.95
- Available In-Store Only Our pumpkin bread in muffin style - with chocolate chips & nuts.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- In-Store Pick-Up, Morning Rolls
Pumpkin Scone (In-Store Pickup)
- $3.00
- Available In-Store Only A fall special treat of a pumpkin scone made with real pumpkin. Soft center topped with cream cheese icing.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Bars
Zucchini Bars (In-Store Pickup)
- $3.50
- Available In-Store Only! Buttery oatmeal crumble and fresh zucchini from customers' gardens.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- In-Store Pick-Up, Pastries
Almond Horn (In-Store Pickup)
- $3.00
- Bursting at the seams with smooth, decadent almond flavor, these marzipan-filled Almond Horns are the perfect choice for an elegant brunch or tea, or just treating yourself to a delicious treat! (Because of course, you deserve it)
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Breads, In-Store Pick-Up
Alpen Bröt (In-Store Pickup)
- $5.25
- For the health-conscious and the foodies alike, our Alpen Bröt combines whole wheat and sourdough for a medium-light bread that’s not light on flavor! Wonderful for toasting, this traditional bread goes with both sweet toppings, like your favorite jam, and savory ones, like as a blank canvas for a gourmet grilled cheese.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Springerli (In-Store Pickup)
- $25.00
- Ground anise seed gives these traditional hand-pressed German cookies an irresistible black licorice aroma and flavor, and the delicate dough gives every bite of these beautiful treats a light crunch. Available year-round to help keep the holiday spirit alive in both your heart AND your taste buds! Sold by the pound. Price reflects pound price.
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Breads, Coffeecakes, In-Store Pick-Up
Apple Bread (In-Store Pickup)
- $7.25
- Our thick, delicious homemade bread dough is swirled with rich cinnamon and sweet, tangy apple chunks and topped with a lush drizzle of homemade icing in this delicious bread. Makes amazing French toast, or a wonderful afternoon snack!
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Doughnuts, In-Store Pick-Up
Apple Fritter (In-Store Pickup)
- $2.50
- Available In-Store Only Lusciously deep fried, filled with apples and cinnamon and drizzled with glaze.
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- In-Store Pick-Up, Pastries
Apple Turnover (In-Store Pickup)
- $3.00
- Delicious apple filling snugs up nicely in its delectable puff pastry shell for this all-American bakery item.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Apricot Pockets (In-Store Pickup)
- $25.00
- Available In-Store Only Butter cookie filled with apricot filling. Sold by the pound. Price reflects pound price.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Apricot Pockets (In-Store Pickup)
- $25.00
- Available In-Store Only Butter cookie filled with apricot filling.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Breads, In-Store Pick-Up, Morning Rolls
Gipfel (Swiss Croissant) (In-Store Pickup)
- $4.00
- It’s easy to confuse these tender rolls with croissants on first sight, but one bite will tell you our Gipfels are miles better! While these buttery treats are hand-rolled like a croissant, they feature a richer taste and flakier texture - perfect when eaten au natural, or for spreading with butter or your favorite fruit jam!
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Breads, In-Store Pick-Up
Bavaria-Style Pretzels (In-Store Pickup)
- $4.75
- Available In-Store Only Saturdays Only - Hand-made, traditional Bavaria-style salted pretzel.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Breads, In-Store Pick-Up
Bavarian Rye (In-Store Pickup)
- $5.25
- Our traditional Bavarian rye bread is as stout and hearty as the people who invented it, many years ago in the Old Country. Today, you can enjoy its rich flavor and thick texture as an accompaniment to your favorite soup, or in an even more traditional way as a Black Forest Ham sandwich!
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Breads, In-Store Pick-Up
BBQ / Dinner Rolls (In-Store Pickup)
- $3.75
- Available In-Store Only BBQ slider sandwiches, smaller portion ham sandwiches or buttered up as is makes a great addition to any meal. Qty: 12
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Chilled Desserts, In-Store Pick-Up
Bienenstitch “Sting of the Bee” (In-Store Pickup)
- $3.75
- Available In-Store Only A slice of German dessert heaven! Signature Buttercream layered between sweet dough, topped with glazed almonds caramelized in REAL honey. *Product is served cold. Transport in cooler during hot weather seasons.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Breads, Coffeecakes, In-Store Pick-Up
Swiss Pear Bread (In-Store Pickup)
- $19.99
- Our delicious Swiss Pear Bread (Birnbrot) is one traditional treat you’ll definitely want to make an everyday habit. We wrap a tender, homemade dough around a bounty of dried pears, dried apples and a cornucopia of spices to create a rich, fruity treat you’ll crave all year long.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Bratzeli (In-Store Pickup)
- $5.50
- Made with lots of fresh butter for a delicately rich flavor, these wafer-thin traditional Swiss cookies are made in tiny batches of just four at a time on a special press imported from Switzerland. Their crispy texture and delicate old-world flavor will make you feel like you’re on a sophisticated European vacation any day!
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Breads, In-Store Pick-Up
Bread Bowls (In-Store Pickup)
- $2.50
- Available In-Store Only Call to Order. Our signature Swiss Bread turned into Bread Bowls. Great for dips and soups!
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Bars, In-Store Pick-Up
Brownie (In-Store Pickup)
- $3.00
- Available In-Store Only A delectable dessert that is cakey on the outside and fudgy in the middle.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Butter Star Cookies (In-Store Pickup)
- $22.00
- If your “childhood favorite” cookie was fresh homemade sugar cookies, this treat is for you! These buttery star cookies are generously iced with creamy homemade icing and topped off with colorful seasonal sprinkles. A tin of these makes an ideal teacher’s gift, thank-you gift, or even a “just because”! Sold by the pound. Price reflects pound price.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Breads, In-Store Pick-Up
Buttercrust White Bread (In-Store Pickup)
- $3.75
- Available In-Store Only Mildly sweet sandwich bread with a buttery crust that is deliciously soft.
-
-
-
-
Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Sheet Cakes
Custom 1/8 Sheet Cake
- $22.00 – $24.20
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup timelines, serving sizes, etc. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking. (Max Servings 12)
-
-
-
-
Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Sheet Cakes
Custom 1/4 Sheet Cake
- $39.00 – $42.90
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup timelines, serving sizes, etc. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking. (Max Servings 24)
-
-
-
-
Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Sheet Cakes
Custom 1/2 Sheet Cake
- $55.00 – $60.50
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup timelines, serving sizes, etc. *Requires a $20 non-refundable deposit. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking. (Max Servings 48)
-
-
-
-
Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Sheet Cakes
Custom Full Sheet Cake
- $80.00 – $88.00
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup timelines, serving sizes, etc. *Requires a $20 non-refundable deposit. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking. (Max Servings 96)
-
-
-
-
Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Wedding Cakes
Tasting Cake
- $25.00
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup, serving sizes, etc. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking.
-
-
-
-
-
-
Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Round Cakes
Custom 6″ Round Cake
- $25.00 – $27.50
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup timelines, serving sizes, etc. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking. (Max Servings 8)
-
-
-
-
-
Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Round Cakes
Custom 8″ Round Cake
- $39.00 – $42.90
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup timelines, serving sizes, etc. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking. (Max Servings 20)
-
-
-
-
Select options
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Wedding Cakes
Wedding Cake – 2 Tier
- Start here to design your wedding cake. 6" top, 8" bottom (Max Servings 28) 6" top, 10" bottom (Max Servings 58) 6" top, 12" bottom (Max Servings 68) 8" top, 10" bottom (Max Servings 70) 8" top, 12" bottom (Max Servings 80) Choose your favorite cake and filling combinations Upload images of the designs you have in mind.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Select options
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Wedding Cakes
Wedding Cake – 3 Tier
- Start here to design your wedding cake. 6" top, 8" middle, 10" bottom (Max Servings 75) 6" top, 8" middle, 12" bottom (Max Servings 95) 6" top, 10" middle, 12" bottom (Max Servings 110) 8" top, 10" middle, 12" bottom (Max Servings 120) Choose your favorite cake and filling combinations Upload images of the designs you have in mind.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup
- Doughnuts, In-Store Pick-Up
Cheese-Filled Donut (In-Store Pickup)
- $2.75
- A soft pillow-y donut, filled with creamy cheese. 24-hour notice
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Breads, In-Store Pick-Up
Cheezy Baked Potato Bread (In-Store Pickup)
- $6.00
- If there was ever a bread that is straight-up, stand-alone delicious, this is it! Golden cheddar cheese and fresh chives dance through a soft white potato bread for an utterly unique and dangerously delicious taste experience.
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cheesecakes, In-Store Pick-Up
Cherry Cheesecake (In-Store Pickup)
- $7.50
- Available In-Store Only Creamy original cheesecake topped with sweet and juicy cherry compote.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- In-Store Pick-Up, Pastries
Cherry Puff (In-Store Pickup)
- $3.00
- A burst of ripe, red cherry filling in a plump puff pastry wrapping, drizzled with a luscious trail of creamy icing.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cheesecakes, In-Store Pick-Up
Chocolate Chip Cheesecake (In-Store Pickup)
- $7.50
- Available In-Store Only Semi-sweet mini chocolate chips meet original cheesecake. Say "cheese" to your new chocolatey friend!
-
-