We are thrilled to share our products that are available for in-store pick-up at New Glarus Bakery.
Explore our range of delectable products that have been crafted with the utmost care and dedication. From freshly baked artisanal bread and pastries that embody the essence of traditional European flavors to delightful cakes and cookies that satisfy your sweetest cravings, our selection caters to every palate.
By choosing in-store pick-up, you not only save on shipping costs but also get to enjoy the warmth and aroma of our bakery as you collect your order.
Embrace the ease of online shopping while relishing the authentic tastes that New Glarus Bakery is renowned for. Place your order today and experience a seamless blend of convenience and culinary delight.
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- In-Store Pick-Up, Pastries
Almond Horn (In-Store Pickup)
- $3.00
- Available In-Store Only Our buttery, house-made puff pastry dough, wrapped around a melting filling of sweet marzipan and finished with a delicate vanilla icing drizzle.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Breads, In-Store Pick-Up
Alpen Bröt (In-Store Pickup)
- $5.75
- Available In-Store Only Whole wheat sourdough with a thick crust.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Springerli (In-Store Pickup)
- $25.00
- Available In-Store Only Traditional hand-pressed German cookies with an irresistible black licorice aroma and flavor. A delicate crunch to a beautiful cookie. Sold by weight. Price reflects pound price.
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Breads, Coffeecakes, In-Store Pick-Up
Apple Bread (In-Store Pickup)
- $7.25
- Available In-Store Only Soft cinnamon swirl bread with chunks of apples and homemade vanilla icing.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Doughnuts, In-Store Pick-Up
Apple Fritter (In-Store Pickup)
- $2.50
- Available In-Store Only Lusciously deep fried, filled with apples and cinnamon and drizzled with glaze.
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- In-Store Pick-Up, Pastries
Apple Turnover (In-Store Pickup)
- $3.00
- Available In-Store Only Made with our homemade puff pastry, stuffed with apple filling, and topped off with a drizzle of vanilla glaze.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Apricot Spritz (In-Store Pickup)
- $25.00
- Available In-Store Only Buttery delights with apricot filling in celebration of Christmas in July Sold by the pound.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Breads, In-Store Pick-Up, Morning Rolls
Gipfel (Swiss Croissant) (In-Store Pickup)
- $3.75
- Available In-Store Only A buttery treat that's hand-rolled like a croissant, but featuring a richer taste and flakier texture.
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies
Basle Leckerli (In-Store Pickup)
- $25.00
- Available In-Store Only This traditional Swiss bar cookie boasts a symphony of rich flavors like honey, almonds, Kirsch liqueur, orange, cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves, all coming together to create a decadently sweet-and-spicy base for a creamy white chocolate finis Sold by the pound. Price reflects 1 lb.
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Breads, In-Store Pick-Up
Bavaria-Style Pretzels (In-Store Pickup)
- $4.75
- Available In-Store, Saturdays Only Hand-made, traditional Bavaria-style salted pretzel.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Breads, In-Store Pick-Up
Bavarian Rye (In-Store Pickup)
- $5.75
- Available In-Store Only A combination of sourdough white dough and dark rye flour, dusted with white rye flour.
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Breads, In-Store Pick-Up
BBQ / Dinner Rolls (In-Store Pickup)
- $3.85
- Available In-Store Only BBQ slider sandwiches, smaller portion ham sandwiches or buttered up as is makes a great addition to any meal. Qty: 12
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Chilled Desserts, In-Store Pick-Up
Bienenstitch “Sting of the Bee” (In-Store Pickup)
- $3.75
- Available In-Store Only A slice of German dessert heaven! Signature Buttercream layered between sweet dough, topped with glazed almonds caramelized in REAL honey. *Product is served cold. Transport in cooler during hot weather seasons.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cheesecakes, In-Store Pick-Up
Black Raspberry Apple Cheesecake (In-Store Pickup)
- $7.50
- Available In-Store Only Black raspberry and apple jelly swirled in original cheesecake.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Bratzeli (In-Store Pickup)
- $5.75
- Available In-Store Only Made with lots of fresh butter for a delicately rich flavor, these wafer-thin traditional Swiss cookies are made in tiny batches of just four at a time on a special press imported from Switzerland.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Breads, In-Store Pick-Up
Bread Bowls (In-Store Pickup)
- $2.50
- Available In-Store Only. Call to Order. Our signature Swiss Bread turned into Bread Bowls. Great for dips and soups!
-
-
-
-
(In-Store Pickup)
- Breads, In-Store Pick-Up
Breadstix (In-Store Pickup)
- $6.95
- Savory, buttery, crunchy, best describes our 30+ year love affair with our Plain Breadstix.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Butter Cookie Assortment – Fall/Winter (In-Store Pickup)
- $25.00
- Available for In-Store Pickup! The most popular butter cookies of the season have finally come together in one mouth-watering seasonal assortment chock-full of holiday flavors. Enjoy Cherry, Raspberry, Lemon, Apricot and Vanilla Spritz, Chocolate Black Raspberry Spritz, Sandbissen Shortbread and Butter Stars, all beautifully decorated with their own seasonal touches and hand-packed in a decorative tin or a plain box.…
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Butter Vanilla Fruit Spritz Assortment (In-Store Pickup)
- $25.00
- Available In-Store Only Butter vanilla spritz cookies with raspberry, lemon, apricot fruit fillings and candied cherry toppings. Only available Nov - Dec 16 oz per order, approx 24-30 cookies
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Butter Star Cookies (In-Store Pickup)
- $20.00
- Available In-Store Only Butter stars are hand-iced and sprinkled with colors of the season. Sold by the pound. Price reflects pound price.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Breads, In-Store Pick-Up
Buttercrust White Bread (In-Store Pickup)
- $3.75
- Available In-Store Only Mildly sweet sandwich bread with a buttery crust that is deliciously soft.
-
-
-
-
Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Sheet Cakes
Custom 1/8 Sheet Cake
- Price range: $27.00 through $29.70
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup timelines, serving sizes, etc. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking. (Max Servings 12)
-
-
-
-
Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Sheet Cakes
Custom 1/4 Sheet Cake
- Price range: $40.00 through $44.00
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup timelines, serving sizes, etc. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking. (Max Servings 24)
-
-
-
-
Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Sheet Cakes
Custom 1/2 Sheet Cake
- Price range: $60.00 through $66.00
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup timelines, serving sizes, etc. *Requires a $20 non-refundable deposit. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking. (Max Servings 48)
-
-
-
-
Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Sheet Cakes
Custom Full Sheet Cake
- Price range: $90.00 through $99.00
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup timelines, serving sizes, etc. *Requires a $20 non-refundable deposit. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking. (Max Servings 96)
-
-
-
-
Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Wedding Cakes
Tasting Cake
- $27.00
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup, serving sizes, etc. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Round Cakes
Custom 6″ Round Cake
- Price range: $27.00 through $29.70
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup timelines, serving sizes, etc. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking. (Max Servings 8)
-
-
-
-
-
Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Round Cakes
Custom 8″ Round Cake
- Price range: $40.00 through $44.00
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup timelines, serving sizes, etc. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking. (Max Servings 20)
-
-
-
-
Select options
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Wedding Cakes
Wedding Cake – 2 Tier
- Start here to design your wedding cake. 6" top, 8" bottom (Max Servings 28) 6" top, 10" bottom (Max Servings 58) 6" top, 12" bottom (Max Servings 68) 8" top, 10" bottom (Max Servings 70) 8" top, 12" bottom (Max Servings 80) Choose your favorite cake and filling combinations Upload images of the designs you have in mind.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Select options
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Wedding Cakes
Wedding Cake – 3 Tier
- Start here to design your wedding cake. 6" top, 8" middle, 10" bottom (Max Servings 75) 6" top, 8" middle, 12" bottom (Max Servings 95) 6" top, 10" middle, 12" bottom (Max Servings 110) 8" top, 10" middle, 12" bottom (Max Servings 120) Choose your favorite cake and filling combinations Upload images of the designs you have in mind.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup
- Doughnuts, In-Store Pick-Up
Cheese-Filled Donut (In-Store Pickup)
- $2.75
- Available In-Store Only (with 24-hour notice) A soft pillow-y donut, filled with creamy cheese.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Breads, In-Store Pick-Up
Cheezy Baked Potato Bread (In-Store Pickup)
- $6.25
- Available In-Store Only Golden cheddar cheese and fresh chives dance through a soft white potato bread for an utterly unique and dangerously delicious taste experience.
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cheesecakes, In-Store Pick-Up
Cherry Cheesecake (In-Store Pickup)
- $7.50
- Available In-Store Only Creamy original cheesecake topped with sweet and juicy cherry compote.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- In-Store Pick-Up, Pastries
Cherry Puff (In-Store Pickup)
- $3.00
- A burst of ripe, red cherry filling in a plump puff pastry wrapping, drizzled with a luscious trail of house-made vanilla glaze.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Chocolate Black Raspberry Spritz (In-Store Pickup)
- $25.00
- Available In-Store Only Chocolaty butter spritz cookie topped with black raspberry filling, dusted with confectionery sugar. Sold by the pound. Price reflects one pound order.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cheesecakes, In-Store Pick-Up
Chocolate Chip Cheesecake (In-Store Pickup)
- $7.50
- Available In-Store Only Semi-sweet mini chocolate chips meet original cheesecake. Say "cheese" to your new chocolatey friend!
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Apple Oatmeal Cookie (In-Store Pickup)
- $16.00
- Available In-Store Only! Cinnamon apple pie filling swirled into buttery oatmeal cookie dough.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Chocolate Chip Cookies (In-Store Pickup)
- $16.00
- Available In-Store Only Packed with chocolate chips, delightfully chewy in the center, with crisp edges. Sold by the pound. Price reflects 1 pound.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Bars, In-Store Pick-Up
Chocolate Oat Bars (In-Store Pickup)
- $3.00
- Decadent bars made with layers of smooth, creamy dark chocolate confection over our homemade buttery oatmeal crumble base.
-
-
-
-
Order for In-Store Pickup!
- Cookies, In-Store Pick-Up
Molasses Cookies (In-Store Pickup)
- $16.00
- Available In-Store Only Old-fashioned molasses cookies that will remind you of Grandma's gingerbread cookies. Sold by the pound. Price reflects 1 pound.
-
-